🔗 Share this article

Acknowledging required adjustments

Ruben Amorim's preferred three-at-the-back system isn't the root cause of the Red Devils' struggles. The Manchester giants are bouncing back from decades of mismanagement and the current squad remains in transition, displaying quality in particular roles while glaring deficiencies remain elsewhere.

That said, structural vulnerabilities characterize Amorim's preferred formation, most notably numerical disadvantages in the middle and issues out wide that require immediate attention. Previous managers have successfully managed analogous problems – the former Chelsea boss with Chelsea and Oliver Glasner with the Eagles demonstrate that positional flexibility matters more than starting positions.

United's coach recently declared: "The tactical setup isn't at fault, the results are," which resembles addressing consequences while ignoring underlying problems. Rival clubs have consistently exploited identical vulnerabilities in United's setup for multiple months, not because of player misunderstanding but because the system itself contains inherent flaws.

Consequently, there won't be a magical fix where the system suddenly works, similar to big-money transfers won't automatically solve the core challenges. Brentford's recent performance acts as a prime case – although they lost their head coach and key players during the break, they adjusted their system intentionally to expose Amorim's unchanged tactics.

When the former Ajax coach came to the club, it was soon clear that Eredivisie success wouldn't translate to English football; his refusal to modify was fundamental in his ultimate failure. Currently the Portuguese manager – who appears to possess the complete skill set for management's greatest challenge except tactical flexibility – is repeating the same pattern and squandering an unprecedented opening. For the first time United maintains leadership committed to winning trophies rather than financial gain.

Changing center-back responsibilities

Outside centre-backs serve important purposes in United's formation: they drive into midfield, perform defensive interventions, monitor spaces, alter attacking focus, initiate attacks and join offensive phases. Any tactical analyst may ask whether deploying two of such versatile players in a back three seems reasonable when a back four could solve central problems.

Currently, these centre-backs remain constrained by enemy strikers who, by standing nearby, prevent them from supporting central areas as the tactics demand. This circumstance enables opponents with extra players to circumvent the middle third, causing pressing concerns that require resolution.

Possible solutions include directing defenders to join midfield despite risks – although this could leave defensive exposure – or dropping Matheus Cunha to improve build-up play, limiting forward options but exploiting his driving runs. The most sensible change involves changing the high-press system from the existing high-risk formation to a more balanced 4-4-2 that ensures superior organization and eliminates the need for centre-backs to push forward.

Bringing back the young midfielder

United's current tactical plan of rapid transitions demands that United abandon midfield control and rely on long balls, counting on individual brilliance rather than structured attacking patterns. Although expected goals data suggest improvement, visual evidence show that recent scoring opportunities result primarily from fouls in the box and low-probability efforts rather than consistent attacking.

Elite clubs manage proceedings through tempo manipulation. United's inability to achieve this isn't completely attributable on the manager's tactics; sources suggest he asked for central additions during the summer window but encountered resistance from football director. Setting aside responsibility, the current situation cannot continue.

The regular central duo of the experienced midfielders, with Manuel Ugarte offering backup, has minimized appearances for the academy graduate. While legitimate concerns exist about his athletic maturity and progressive passing, excluding such talent raises questions about the tactical plan's suitability.

The current midfield options personify fast-paced play, whereas Mainoo offers tempo control. With his former club, his squad could play direct football due to technical advantage against most Primeira Liga opponents, confident they would recover possession if the attack broke down. However in the Premier League, the standard throughout means sloppy ball circulation receives instant retribution, while physical dominance alone won't secure results.

Mainoo's technical quality impresses observers, and although combining him with Fernandes creates defensive concerns, such deficiencies prove less important in a controlling side. Accounting for current statistics showing they allow superior scoring situations than any league rival, utilizing the academy product looks logical to test as different methods have already failed. Although questions persist about his precise contribution in the current setup, match experience represents the optimal growth route and probably wouldn't damage the current situation.

Maximizing flank contributions

Down the right flank, the pairing of Amad Diallo and Bryan Mbeumo should theoretically work given their shared attributes of creativity, intelligence and determination. When combined with Leny Yoro, they might create a dangerous triangle that enhances attacking options. At present though, static movement makes opponents' jobs simpler for organized defenses.

Amorim must implement systematic movement drills that create uncertainty through constant positional changes. Service into wide areas need to demonstrate variety – not always to feet but often into space to optimize forward movement. This tactic facilitates cutting inside, beating defenders and generating opportunities for shots or crosses.

On the opposite flank, Patrick Dorgu frequently receives possession in advanced areas even without the technical refinement to utilize productively. Modifying his role a bit more defensive would employ his recovery skills and ball-carrying strength to {supply more creative players|service better attackers|provide for